Category Archives: Development

Round 3 Comments: HKR get out the vote… again

The Discovery Bay developer, Hong Kong Resort Company Limited (HKR), may ignore the public comments in their own submissions to the Town Planning Board (TPB). However, they certainly do not ignore them when it comes time to drum up support for their proposals.

Yet again, HKR have organised their staff and fellow travelers to bombard the TPB with the same standard phrases they have used since Round 1.

For both Area 6f and 10b, CM Manager GH Koo takes the prize for the first to comment in Round 3. The 525 supporting comments for Area 6f #4692 to #5217, which were submitted to the TPB in one batch, are listed separately so you can save bandwidth.

See #5218 of Area 6f for a comment spoken from the heart by a Parkvale resident. These simple words underline how callous HKR really are.

The Peninsula VOC’s submission is included at #4683 of Area 10b (the last entry in the file).

Area 6f

4492 to 4691

4692 to 5217 (You’ve seen one, you’ve seen them all)

5218 to 5262

5263 to 5297

5298 to 5411

Area 10b

4479 to 4683

4684 to 5200 (You’ve seen one, you’ve seen them all)

5201 to 5390

No second chances?

Think again!

You now have a FOURTH chance to comment on the Area 6f and 10b plans.

New submissions for both 6f and 10b were posted on the Town Planning Board website on 9 December. Deadline for public comments is 30 December, 2016.

The date of the Town Planning Board meeting to hear the two applications has now been pushed back to 17 February, 2017.

Gist of updated submission for Area 6f

Gist of updated submission for Area 10b

The full updated submissions will be posted here when available.

Area 10b — Round 3

The Area 10b submission may be downloaded in two parts.

Area 10b Round 3 Part 1

Area 10b Round 3 Part 2

To make new comments to the Town Planning Board on Area 10b (service area below Peninsula), or resubmit your previous comments, go to http://www.info.gov.hk/tpb/en/plan_application/Y_I-DB_3.html. Alternatively, you may submit your comments by email at tpbpd@pland.gov.hk. If submitting by email, include the reference “Y/I-DB/3” in the subject line.

The deadline for submissions is 9 December, 2016. The revised date of the Town Planning Board meeting to consider the Area 6f application is 13 January, 2017.

Area 6f — Round 3

HKR has submitted a revised application to the Town Planning Board. Shockingly, they have completely ignored the many significant and well-researched comments made by residents of Discovery Bay during the previous two rounds of public consultation.

The full updated submission may be downloaded here.

To make new comments to the Town Planning Board on Area 6f (area behind Parkvale), or resubmit your previous comments, visit http://www.info.gov.hk/tpb/en/plan_application/Y_I-DB_2.html. Alternatively, you may submit your comments by email at tpbpd@pland.gov.hk. If submitting by email, include the reference “Y/I-DB/2” in the subject line.

The deadline for submissions is 9 December, 2016. The revised date of the Town Planning Board meeting to consider the Area 6f application is 13 January, 2017.

TPB defers decision on 6a and 10b for 2nd time

At the Town Planning Board Meeting on 26 August, the TPB once again agreed to defer a decision on the 6a and 10b applications submitted by Hong Kong Resort Company Limited (HKR).

Judging from the instructions at the time of the last deferment, HKR will likely have two months to submit a revised application, and another round of public consultation will be carried out in October/November.

One interesting bit of news from the meeting. Before proceeding to the next item, the members met in a private session that was not open to members of the public. No details of the discussion during the private session are available, but it may relate to the invalidated public submissions from the last round. The TPB struck off a number of submissions before the meeting  because the identity of the author could not be verified.

Deferred Again

HKR has asked that consideration of its applications for rezoning of Area 6f and 10b be deferred once again. The Town Planning Board (TPB) will consider HKR’s request at its meeting on Friday, 26 August, starting at 2:30pm.

When the TPB granted HKR’s request for deferment last time, at the meeting on 13 May, 2016, the minutes of the meeting stated that:

“The Committee also agreed to advise the applicant that two months were allowed for preparation of the submission of the further information, and no further deferment would be granted unless under very special circumstances.”

Let’s see whether the TPB grants HKR’s request for a second deferment or not.

Area 6f — All Public Comments from Round 2

The comments on the second round of public consultation by the Town Planning Board (TPB) on the Area 6f and 10b development proposals from Hong Kong Resort Company Limited (HKR) are now available for viewing at the TPB offices in North Point.

A total of 2,234 responses were received for 6f in Round 2 (2,257 for Round 1), and 2,330 for 10b (2,149 for Round 1).

Submissions 2863 to 4139 for Area 6f, or 57.1% of the total, were received in a single bundle submitted by hand to the TPB at the same time. All are in favour of the proposal and, judging from the nature of the comments, come from people outside DB.

Links to all comments received for Area 6f in Round 2 are available after the break. Continue reading Area 6f — All Public Comments from Round 2

Parkvale VOC raises alarm on Area 6f development

The Parkvale Village Owners Committee (VOC) has submitted a major review of the Area 6f development proposal to the Town Planning Board in the latest round of public consultation on HKR’s application to amend the Discovery Bay Outline Zoning Plan, which ended at midnight on 15 July.

No submission was made by the Peninsula VOC. In fact, the topic was not even on the agenda of the Peninsula VOC meeting of 5 July. This is surprising, as the Area 10b plan proposes that a Sewage Treatment Works be built at the entrance to Peninsula Village, after levelling the existing wooded hillock.